“The people of Monroe Township have used their First Amendment-protected freedom of speech to speak up against data centers. Hexa Builders’ bricks do not have that same right.”
Click here for link to the amicus brief.
(Camden, NJ) — Tech Justice Law today filed an amicus brief in the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey in response to Hexa Builders’ claim that Monroe Township’s data center ban violates the First Amendment – a blatant attempt to squash rising discontent around data centers. The brief, which urges the court to reject Hexa’s First Amendment theory and to respect the Township’s authority to make land-use decisions for its residents, was co-authored by Olivier Sylvain, Professor of Law at Fordham University School of Law, and Laura Bingham, Practice Professor of Law and the Executive Director of the Institute for Law, Innovation, and Technology (iLIT) at Temple University Beasley School of Law.
“As Americans make it clear that they are not interested in tech companies building data centers in their community for dangerous Artificial Intelligence products, these companies are making increasingly ridiculous appeals to the law to let construction go forward. It should be up to the people of Monroe Township, not outside actors with financial interests, to protect their residents, and the court must affirm their right to do so,” said Meetali Jain, Founding Executive Director of Tech Justice Law. “The people of Monroe Township have used their First Amendment-protected freedom of speech to speak up against data centers. Hexa Builders’ bricks do not have that same right.”
Hexa Builders’ lawsuit is centered around Monroe Township Council Ordinance O:25-2026, which banned data centers in every zoning district in the township. The construction company had received approval to build warehouses on the site and then sought to convert one of them into a data center. Despite lacking a tenant for the building, Hexa Builders claims the ban violates equal protection laws because data centers are “similar to other warehouse and storage facilities,” and the First Amendment, because data centers that power AI are a “medium of communication and expression.”
The lawsuit is yet another absurd attempt to claim the inalienable rights granted to humans in the Constitution for corporations. But building and operating a data center is not expressive activity, data centers are not mediums of communication, and AI output is not automatically speech. To treat the buildings that might house AI servers as such is a ridiculous contention that would put ordinary zoning of power plants, warehouses, and other infrastructure under First Amendment scrutiny.
Tech Justice Law further argues that local governments are best positioned to protect their residents, even when new technology is involved. Weighing the effects of large facilities against the water, energy, noise, and electricity costs is a core responsibility that must be left in their jurisdiction. Additionally, data centers are general-purpose infrastructure, and the laws that govern them must therefore be about infrastructure rather than a company’s speech.
“This is little more than a cute attempt at an end run around lawful democratic lawmaking processes. There is nothing about the ordinance that impedes free speech. To the contrary, Monroe Township’s decision to stand-up against the construction of facilities that we know are disproportionately extractive and costly for local residents is a prudent exercise of democratic initiative,” said Olivier Sylvain, Professor of Law at Fordham University School of Law. “It is a clear-eyed effort that sees past the glossy promises about AI development – a welcome endeavor to protect ordinary people from an industry that would rather remain unfettered no matter the material costs.”
“Local communities are where the AI industry is meeting the democratic process in this country, forced to face the just reality that concentrating power in the hands of the few at the expense of the many is antithetical to our system of government. Gaming that system can only get you so far and resistance to unaccountable power is the core of the First Amendment,” said Laura Bingham, Executive Director of the Institute for Law, Innovation, and Technology (iLIT) at Temple University Beasley School of Law. “Hexa Builders seeks a Bill of Rights to serve its own interests. No court, legislature, or community should bow to such a baseless demand. We have real problems to solve and communities like Monroe Township are hard at work doing just that.”
The complete amicus brief can be viewed HERE.
#####
TECH JUSTICE LAW (“TJL”) is a pioneering strategic litigation and advocacy organization bringing justice to communities harmed by tech products. TJL co-filed the first-ever, groundbreaking lawsuits against a popular, “AI” chatbot product developed by Character AI, with support by Google, raising public awareness of chatbots’ real-world harms. TJL’s cases and advocacy have also focused government attention on harmful AI products, including unlicensed therapy chatbots. TJL brings together legal experts, policy advocates, digital rights organizations, and technologists to ensure that our legal protections are fit for the digital age.